Broken Chair Injury
When Alonso sat down in a chair at a photography studio, the chair broke and caused serious injury. Who was responsible for those injuries? Alonso called us and we helped him get the money he deserved.
This is a story of an actual case handled by the team at Kane & Silverman. The names and exact details of the situation have been changed to protect the identities of the parties involved.
Case Type: Premises Liability and Product Liability
Location: Pennsylvania
Injuries: Back Injury
Initial Offer From Insurance: $0
Final Settlement: $800,000
Year of Final Settlement: 2020
Attorney: Howard G. Silverman
Case Study
Alonso and his wife, Camila, went to the mall to have pictures taken. What was going to be a fun trip for the couple, turned into a lot of medical bills. Alonso was sitting on a chair that broke, causing a serious back injury. They came to us for help.
Faulty Product Liability
Alonso told us about how he was sitting at the photo studio. He was in the chair for about 15 minutes. He and his wife were reviewing photos with the photographer. But, the chair broke. It was so unexpected, Alonso was not shifting in his chair, it just broke. Then, he was on the floor in extreme pain.
At first, this sounded like a premises liability case. But, then we found other evidence that included product liability.
Our team contacted the photography studio. The studio was a chain, and the corporate office directed us to a furniture supplier. The chain had purchased a lot of chairs from the same furniture supplier.

Faulty Chair Manufacturer
We talked to the chair supplier. They claimed there was nothing wrong with the chairs. But, somehow several chairs used in the photography studio chain broke and hurt people. Through further digging, we found only the chairs sold to the studios were “faulty.” Something wasn’t right. We kept investigating.
Emails Point To A Problem
Our team gathered further evidence from the photo studio and furniture supplier. We poured over emails and documents. Our team reviewed assembly instructions. Then, we found the problem. The chairs were all assembled without a part. A small screw was needed to hold each leg in place. Those screws were missing. But, who assembled the chairs? Who was responsible?

Shared Liability
The chair was assembled wrong. We established that. We found the furniture supplier had put the chairs together and delivered them to the studios. But, the photo studio corporate office knew about the problem with the chair failures and continued to use them. Both companies shared responsibility for Alonso’s injury. And, we built Alonso’s case to prove it in court.
Broken Chair Injury Lawsuit
This case started as a premises liability lawsuit. But, that changed to a premises liability and product liability case. The defendants were pointing fingers at each other. Evidence showed both companies were aware of the problem, but neither company had done anything to fix the problem. Alonso needed help.
Alonso was hurt. Our investigation found who was responsible. Now, we prepared our case to prove both company’s negligence in court.
We tried to offer mediation, but the defense refused. So, we prepared our case against them in court. A week before the trial, the defense changed their attitude and agreed to settle. We negotiated an $800,000 settlement for Alonso’s injury.

Philadelphia Chair Injury Lawyer
We’ve been helping people like Alonso since 1990. Our experienced legal team got him the results he deserved, we can help you too. Please call our office at 215-232-1000 to talk to a member of our legal team about your situation. We’ll be happy to answer your questions, free of charge. Or, you can fill out our online form to schedule a free injury consultation.
We don’t charge any legal fees unless we recover money for you.
