Foot Injury Case Study
Foot Injury $3.8 Million Jury Verdict
Archer Davies was working as a sheet metal mechanic on a construction job site. He was on a job in the Harrisburg area when another sub-contractor’s employee ran over his heel with a tow motor. He came to us a year after his foot injury. We turned a worker’s comp claim into an injury case against the sub-contractor and contractor at the job site. Archer received a $3.8 million jury verdict for his injury.
This is a story of an actual case handled at Kane & Silverman. The names and exact details of the situation have been changed to protect the identities of the parties involved.
Case Type: Workplace Injury – Construction Site
Location: Pennsylvania
Date of Incident: 2010
Injuries: Permanent Heel Injury, Ongoing Pain, Difficulty Walking
Initial Offer From Insurance: $0
Final Settlement: $3,800,000
Date of Final Settlement: 2019
Attorney: Howard G. Silverman
On the job site, another subcontractor reversed nearby on a tow motor. The tow motor operator was too close and drove over Mr. Davies’ heel. At first, Archer thought his foot would be okay. It was painful, sure, but it didn’t seem he broke any bones. Find out how we got him nearly $3.8 million for his injury.

Report The Injury
Whenever a work-related injury happens, always report it to your supervisor. That’s what Archer did. He reported the incident, but Mr. Davies thought he was okay to continue working. He didn’t see a doctor the day of the injury.
RELATED ARTICLES:
Construction Accident Injuries
Independent Contractor Injury
Contractors Insurance
The Pain Gets Worse
Archer continued to work, with his hurt foot, for several weeks. About three weeks after the incident, things weren’t getting better. That’s when he went to see the doctor. The pain was getting worse. After some testing, the doctor didn’t find anything out of the ordinary. He released Archer to return to work but sent him for physical therapy.
Several Months Later
Archer is a real trooper. For several months, he works through this pain while receiving treatment. But as time goes by, Archer doesn’t get better. In fact, his pain gets worse.
Podiatrist Diagnosis
Archer sees a specialist about his pain from the injury. The doctor finds Archer has plantar fasciitis and inferior calcaneal bursitis. This is a direct result of the tow motor injury. The doctor provided custom orthotics for Archer to wear in his shoe. Archer also agreed to steroid injections in the heel to relieve the constant pain.
Painful Treatment
The pain in Archer’s heel is bad. It wakes him up at night. His foot has a constant “pins and needles” feeling. Walking is so painful, he starts using a cane. His doctor recommends steroid injections might relieve the pain. But, the injections are painful and relief only lasts a few months.
Fired From Work
Even though Archer continued to work through his injury, the pain was getting worse. His doctor placed him on light duty restrictions to allow the foot to heal. But, Archer’s employer decided to let him go. That is when Archer started looking for an attorney.

When To Hire An Attorney
Everyone wants to do the right thing. If you have a job site injury, don’t wait to call a lawyer for advice. A good lawyer can provide a confidential consultation. You’ll also get free advice to protect your rights moving forward. Additionally, having an injury doesn’t always lead to a lawsuit. But if it does, you’ll be sure you’ve been protecting yourself from the beginning.
In Archer’s case, it is better the employer fired him when they did. In a personal injury case, the statute of limitations is typically two years from the date of the incident in Pennsylvania. But, the time limit on his construction injury case started the day of his injury. If Archer waited through all his treatment, it would have dragged out for years. After two years, he wouldn’t have been able to file a claim. He would be stuck with the injury and no money for all the future medical bills.
Archer’s employer paid the medical bills under worker’s comp. But, they didn’t cover the other added expenses. Archer was driving, sometimes hours, to doctor appointments. On top of his time, he was putting a lot of wear and tear on his car. Plus, he needed to fill his gas tank more often. Archer deserves compensation for his time, expenses, pain, and more.

Construction Injury Lawsuit
The details of Archer’s injury incident made him eligible to file an injury claim against the sub-contractor and other parties involved. When he started looking for an attorney, he called several firms for help. He also interviewed several law firms before picking a firm where he felt comfortable – we were one of several firms he met for a free consultation. After a week, he called us back to sign up with us. Our team went right to work building his case.
We found the subcontractor that ran over his heel was negligent. They did not train their employees for tow motor safety. The company also failed to have a spotter to ensure safety around the tow motor while it was in motion. Our team also discovered the lead contractor shared some of the blame. This was the grounds for a construction injury lawsuit. We built the case for Archer and took it to the next step, mediation.
Mediation
Mediation is an alternative to taking a case to civil court. It is not necessary, but mediation can help resolve a case before taking it to a jury. In mediation, all parties involved agree to discuss their case with a neutral party. The neutral person hears both sides and tries to work out the issues preventing a successful settlement between both parties.
The defense agreed to meet in mediation to help settle the case out of court. In mediation, the mediator suggested a $1 million settlement. The insurance company offered $800,000. The decision to settle or proceed was up to Archer, but we thought we could do better for him if we took his case all the way to trial. He declined the settlement offer and we took the case to court before a jury.
Foot Injury Lawsuit
It took months of preparation to get Archer’s case ready for jury trial. In court, both sides presented their case. The case took four days and the jury deliberated for about two hours. After hearing the evidence, the Harrisburg jury awarded Archer Davies $2.87 million for his injury. On top of that, he received nearly $1 million in delay damages. All told, Mr. Davies gets roughly $3.8 million for his construction site foot injury.
Howard Silverman represented Mr. Davies in court. The legal team assisted with research, gathering documents, evidence, and managing the case. You can read more about this case in this Legal Intelligencer article.
Construction Injury Lawyer In Pennsylvania and New Jersey
Kane & Silverman has been helping people like Archer since 1990. If you have any questions about a construction injury, contact us. We help injured people in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Maryland.
Call or text us at 215-232-1000. Or, use our online form to schedule a free construction injury consultation. Our injury lawyers will listen to your situation and offer sound advice. All consultations are free and confidential. You don’t pay us anything unless we recover money for you.
